Should Maya and Jordan split the $2,400 vet bill for their shared dog evenly, or should Jordan pay more?
Use the browser print dialog and choose Save as PDF.
Position A: Maya's Position
Fairness 9/10
- The vet bill should be split 50/50, consistent with past agreements.
- Both parties agreed to cancel the pet insurance.
- If income-based splits are used, they should apply to all dog expenses.
- Proposes a 55/45 split for this bill and suggests getting new pet insurance.
Position B: Jordan's Position
Fairness 9/10
- The surgery was due to an incident at Jordan's place, and Maya wanted the insurance canceled.
- An even split disproportionately affects Jordan due to lower income.
- Proposes a 60/40 split for this bill and a future agreement for all costs.
The dog ate a sock while staying at Jordan's place.. Consistent · 60%
Maya makes approximately $30,000 more per year than Jordan.. Consistent · 80%
Bridge Option: 57.5/42.5 Split and Comprehensive Future Plan has the highest minimum acceptability across the positions, at 79.
A suggestion for discussion, not a ruling. Verafy doesn't decide value questions; it shows where the disagreement is and which options each side can live with.